Should People With Flat Feet Wear Barefoot Shoes? Podiatrist Deep Dive

Flat feet affects roughly 20-30% of the population [1]. Most people with flat feet have been told the same thing their entire lives: you need arch support. Then barefoot shoes became popular. Suddenly, the message flipped. Ditch the support. Let your feet work naturally. Strengthen what's weak.

If you have flat feet, you’ve probably wondered: are barefoot shoes good for flat feet, or do they make things worse? The answer depends on your specific foot type, flexible vs. rigid, painful vs. pain-free.

» Get the best exercises for flat feet

How Barefoot Shoes for Flat Feet Change Your Gait

Your foot doesn't move the same way in barefoot shoes compared to traditional supportive footwear.

In walking, heel strike remains your natural first contact point. What changes is how your foot loads afterward. Barefoot shoes encourage more natural foot placement, improve proprioception (your foot's awareness of where it is), and strengthen muscles that sit dormant in supportive shoes.

Running shows more dramatic changes. Barefoot shoes often reduce heel striking and push you toward mid- or forefoot contact.

Research shows this leads to shorter stride length, higher cadence, and less ground contact time [2]. Flat-footed runners also show greater ankle dorsiflexion range, which improves mobility and efficiency.

» Check out the best running insoles for people with flat feet

What Happens to Your Foot Muscles

Without built-in arch support, your intrinsic foot muscles have to work. These are the small muscles responsible for maintaining arch stability.

Research shows that six months of minimal footwear use can increase foot strength by over 57% [3]. Systematic reviews confirm gains in toe flexor strength when switching to minimalist shoes [4]. This strengthening helps counteract the arch collapse common in flat feet.

The strengthening extends past your foot. Muscles like your tibialis posterior and peroneals get recruited more actively. These muscles support better stability and overall lower-leg function.

Think of it like this: supportive shoes are a cast for your foot. Remove the cast, and the muscles underneath need to rebuild.



» Learn to rebuild arches in flat feet

How Your Entire Body Responds

Flat feet don't just affect your feet. They change how forces travel up your legs into your hips and back.

Barefoot shoes can improve alignment throughout your lower body by enhancing sensory input and muscle activation. Increased ground contact awareness encourages better postural control and reduces the compensations flat feet typically create.

Research shows that barefoot walking produces different ground reaction forces and ankle moments, altering knee and ankle kinematics compared to shoes [5].

Barefoot running reduces peak knee forces and shifts loads toward the ankle [6]. Studies also report enhanced proprioception and stability in minimalist shoes, leading to more dynamic, adaptive movement patterns [7].

The load distribution changes occur through improved muscle coordination rather than passive support. This creates more dynamic and adaptive movement patterns.

» Discover the best exercises for collapsed arches and flat feet

Are Barefoot Shoes Good for Flat Feet?

Here's what most people don't understand: arch support can weaken your arches over time. The absence of arch support in barefoot shoes forces your intrinsic foot muscles to actively maintain arch structure. This creates a natural strengthening protocol.

Short-term effects include muscle fatigue and adaptation. Previously underused muscles suddenly have to work. Foot strength and stiffness are related to footwear use, with minimal shoe use potentially reducing flat foot development risk [8].

Long-term benefits include structural improvements in arch function and enhanced muscle coordination. Research following runners using minimal shoes demonstrated measurable increases in arch height and stiffness over 6 months.

This suggests that consistent use can lead to functional improvements even in adults with established flat foot structure [9]. Your foot can adapt. Even if you're 40 or 50 years old.



Do Barefoot Shoes Help Plantar Fasciitis Pain?

Plantar fasciitis is one of the most common complaints from people with flat feet. Barefoot shoes can help, but the transition matters.

A prospective study involving recreational runners with symptomatic plantar fasciitis showed significant pain reduction after a 6-week barefoot running program on grass [10].

At week 6, the average pain score decreased from 3.9 to 2.5. At week 12, it dropped to 1.5. This corresponds to a 38.8% improvement at week 6 and a 58.3% improvement at week 12.

But here's the catch: individuals with flat or high arches may be at increased risk of developing heel pain or exacerbating existing plantar fasciitis if the adaptation process isn't managed properly [11]. A gradual progression allows your foot's tissues to adapt. Rush it, and you risk injury.

» Find out what you need to avoid with plantar fasciitis

Balance and Injury Risk

It’s natural to wonder if barefoot shoes are good for flat feet when it comes to stability and injury prevention. They enhance proprioceptive input and ground contact awareness. This leads to improved balance and stability.

Minimal shoes improve stability and mobility in persons with a history of falls [12]. Research shows no significant dynamic balance differences between barefoot and shod groups, indicating that barefoot shoes don't compromise stability while providing strengthening benefits [13].

The injury risk profile changes with barefoot shoes. Initial transition periods may increase overuse injury risk. Long-term use typically reduces injury rates through improved foot strength and proprioception.

Flat-footed individuals must transition gradually. Your altered biomechanics initially increase stress on previously underused structures during the adaptation period.

» Discover the different types of ankle sprains

Flexible vs. Rigid Flat Feet

Not all flat feet are the same. This distinction matters enormously.

For flexible flat feet, barefoot shoes strengthen intrinsic foot muscles and encourage natural arch development, potentially reducing long-term arch collapse. Studies show that populations who habitually go barefoot have a lower prevalence of flat feet compared to those who wear regular shoes [14].

For rigid flat feet, the arch structure is less adaptable. Barefoot shoes may increase strain and discomfort. While barefoot conditions enhance ankle mobility and foot muscle development, people with rigid arches need a gradual transition and supportive strategies to avoid overuse injuries [15].

The bone structure in rigid flat feet has limited joint mobility due to structural constraints. Strengthening exercises can improve intrinsic muscle strength and force distribution, but they cannot fundamentally alter fixed bony alignment or create joint range of motion that structural limitations prevent.

» Read a PT's opinion on the best footwear and insoles for flat feet

Who Should Try Barefoot Shoes

The decision should be made on a case-by-case basis. Current evidence suggests that people with flatter feet typically have more success with stability shoes, but this doesn't universally apply [15].

Key factors include:

• Flat foot type (flexible vs. rigid)
• Current activity level
• Existing pain or dysfunction
• Individual biomechanical patterns

Footwear significantly influences foot structure and mechanics. The wrong choice can exacerbate problems [8]. A gradual assessment approach works best. Start with evaluation of foot flexibility, current strength levels, and response to brief barefoot activities.

Research indicates that barefoot shoes can stabilize flat feet and improve comfort when appropriately implemented. This requires careful monitoring and often professional guidance to prevent overuse injuries during the adaptation period [12].

» Find out why zero-drop shoes are bad for your feet

Who Will Adapt Well to Barefoot Shoes?

Flexible Flat Feet, Active Lifestyle

A person with mild, flexible flat feet who walks, jogs, or practices yoga regularly will likely adapt well.

Barefoot shoes can strengthen intrinsic foot muscles, improve arch function, and enhance balance. Gradual transition ensures minimal soreness. Over time they may notice better overall foot stability and mobility.

Flexible Flat Feet, Sedentary Lifestyle

Someone with flexible flat feet but limited daily activity may still benefit, but progress will be slower. Barefoot shoes can help engage foot muscles. Yet without regular use, adaptations will be minimal. Controlled transition and consistent activity are essential to avoid discomfort or strain.

» Explore invasive and conservative treatments for flat feet

Who Will Struggle With Barefoot Shoes?

Rigid Flat Feet, Moderate Arch Collapse

An individual with rigid arches may experience discomfort. Their foot structure is less adaptable. Barefoot shoes can place extra stress on ligaments and tendons. Without gradual adaptation or orthotic support, they risk pain, overuse injuries, or worsening foot strain.

Severe Rigid Flat Feet, Chronic Pain

People with severe structural collapse or chronic plantar fasciitis may struggle significantly. Barefoot shoes may aggravate symptoms, reduce comfort, and increase joint stress.

In these cases, supportive footwear or orthotics are usually safer. Barefoot use should be limited to controlled rehabilitation under supervision.

» Learn if people with flat feet can be top athletes

How to Safely Transition to Barefoot Shoes

Follow this progressive protocol to minimize injury risk:

1. Begin with 15-20 minutes daily for non-weight bearing activities. Add 15 minutes weekly. Research demonstrates significant foot strength gains occur over 6-month periods, patience is essential [3].
2. Progress surface difficulty strategically. You can start on soft surfaces (grass, carpet) before advancing to harder terrain (concrete, asphalt).
3. Incorporate targeted strengthening. Add toe curls, calf raises, and arch activation drills to accelerate adaptation.
4. Watch for discomfort in the arch, heel, or Achilles tendon. Any pain requires immediate reduction in usage time.
5. Consider transitional support: Use custom orthotics with minimal drop and tailored arch support from companies like Upstep. This bridges the gap between traditional and barefoot shoes while maintaining some structured support.
6. Consult a podiatrist or physical therapist familiar with barefoot transitions.

Studies show minimalist shoes can offer better gait performance than completely barefoot conditions, suggesting structured minimalist options may be safer than immediate barefoot adoption [15].



When Barefoot Shoes Aren't Right

For individuals unsuitable for barefoot shoes, structured support becomes crucial.

Supportive Footwear Options

• Motion Control Shoes: Firm midsoles help control excessive pronation in severe flat feet
• Custom or OTC Orthotic Inserts: Provide arch support and redistribute plantar pressures to reduce strain
• Stability Shoes: Dual-density midsoles offer moderate support without excessive restriction. Research supports that stability shoes are often more successful for people with flatter feet [14]

Complementary Interventions

• Physical Therapy: Focus on posterior tibial tendon strengthening, calf flexibility, and hip stability to address biomechanical deficits contributing to flat foot dysfunction
• Taping and Bracing: Techniques or ankle braces provide temporary support during high-demand activities
• Weight Management: Reduces stress on the foot's supporting structures and improves overall outcomes

The goal is providing external support while building internal strength and flexibility. This may allow future progression to minimal footwear once strength and stability improve.

The Hybrid Approach With Custom Orthotics

Custom orthotics from Upstep offer a middle path. They provide the support needed to prevent pain and injury while you build strength.

You can wear them in regular shoes during your daily activities, then gradually introduce barefoot shoes for controlled periods. This dual approach lets you strengthen your feet without risking injury from too-rapid transition.

Don't let flat feet limit your lift—optimize your performance with custom orthotics

Pay 60% less than any other custom orthotic brand and get a risk-free period of 180 days to try the insoles

Free shipping

100% online

FSA/HSA eligible

Buy Now



Common Misconceptions About Flat Feet

A major misconception is that all flat feet are problematic and require correction. Research shows flat feet are less common in habitually barefoot populations. This suggests some "flat feet" may be adaptations to conventional footwear rather than true structural abnormalities [14].

Many believe flat feet automatically mean weakness. Flexible flat feet can be functionally normal.

Another misconception is that arch support is always necessary. This can actually weaken intrinsic foot muscles over time. People often assume barefoot shoes will immediately "fix" their flat feet. They don't understand the lengthy adaptation process required.

Some believe barefoot shoes are automatically harmful for flat feet. Research shows they can provide stabilization and improved comfort when properly implemented [12].

The distinction between flexible and rigid flat feet is poorly understood. This leads to inappropriate footwear choices. Understanding that foot shape variation is normal helps make better footwear decisions.

» Explore the worst shoes for Achilles tendonitis

Age Matters More Than You Think

Children's feet are naturally flat until ages 6-8. Early barefoot exposure during this critical development period may support natural arch formation. Children who spend more time barefoot develop stronger, better-formed arches compared to those predominantly in supportive shoes.

Older adults face different challenges. Age-related changes in tissue elasticity and balance control require even more gradual transitions. They may benefit from improved proprioception for fall prevention, but the adaptation process takes longer.

Your Environment Changes Everything

Occupational and environmental factors significantly influence success with barefoot shoes.

Healthcare workers, teachers, and retail employees with flat feet face 8-12 hour shifts on hard surfaces. This creates different demands than the controlled progressions typically recommended.

Urban environments with concrete present challenges compared to natural surfaces. This requires specific adaptation strategies for people with flat feet navigating various terrains safely.

» Check out the best insoles for nurses to relieve fatigue

Integrating Other Treatments for Flat Feet

Many people with flat feet are simultaneously pursuing physical therapy, using orthotics, or managing other conditions like diabetes or arthritis. Understanding how barefoot shoes interact with these interventions is crucial. Sometimes they enhance other approaches. Sometimes they conflict.

Sport-specific considerations vary dramatically. A flat-footed runner has different needs than a basketball player or dancer. This requires personalized approaches that consider training cycles and sport-specific movement patterns.

Custom orthotics from Upstep can serve as a bridge. Use them during high-demand activities or long work shifts. Reserve barefoot shoes for controlled strengthening sessions and shorter activities.

This combined approach lets you build foot strength progressively while maintaining the support you need for demanding situations.

» Want to reduce fatigue? Discover the best insoles for standing all day

Making the Right Choice for Your Flat Feet

People with flexible flat feet who are willing to transition gradually can benefit from barefoot shoes. The strengthening effects are real. The improvements in proprioception and balance are measurable.

People with rigid flat feet should approach barefoot shoes with extreme caution. The structural limitations of their feet may make barefoot shoes inappropriate, at least initially.

Everyone considering barefoot shoes should start slowly, monitor carefully, and consider professional guidance. The adaptation period takes months, not weeks. Your feet spent years in supportive shoes. They won't rebuild overnight.

Find Your Perfect Relief

Take our personalized quiz, and let us help you find the ideal insoles to keep you comfortable and on your feet all day.

Take the Quiz