7 Best Cycling Shoe Insoles to Provide Arch Support
Updated May 25, 2023.
Compared to standard running insoles, cycling shoe insoles offer superior arch support, metatarsal padding, and deep heel cups, reducing foot strain during cycling. With the wrong insole, you risk underperforming and developing musculoskeletal problems that may hinder your cycling in the future.
Choosing the right insole can help you avoid this. That’s why we’ve sifted through the market to help you identify the best insoles for your cycling shoes. Here are our top seven picks and why they qualify.
» Will cycling orthotics help your performance? See the benefits of cycling orthotics
Top 7 Insoles for Cycling Shoes with Arch Support
- Best Overall Cycling Insoles: Upstep Cycling Custom Orthotics
- Best Firm Fit Insoles: Tread Labs Lael Wilcox
- Best for Comfort Insoles: Superfeet Trailblazer
- Best Cork Insoles: SOLE Performance Medium
- Best Thin Insoles: Protalus T-100 Elite
- Best Shock-Absorbing Insoles: URthotics Sports
- Best Foam Insoles: FitMyFoot Red Hexagon
1. Best Overall Cycling Insoles
- Custom-made by top podiatrists
- Optimal support and cushioning
- 180-day money-back guarantee
- FSA and HSA eligible
- Free shipping and returns
- Short waiting period before receiving orthotics
When it comes to finding the best insoles for cycling, Upstep is the clear winner. Their custom cycling insoles are made with the highest quality and most durable materials, providing optimal support and cushioning during cycling. But what sets Upstep apart from the rest is its commitment to affordability. These insoles are reasonably priced, making them an excellent choice for cycling enthusiasts on a budget.
What's more, Upstep offers a 100% money-back guarantee on their product for 120 days, with free shipping and returns. And for those who have a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Flexible Spending Account (FSA), Upstep insoles are eligible for reimbursement, making them an even more attractive option for those looking for quality and affordability. With Upstep, you can be sure that you're getting the best cycling insoles for your money.
2. Best Firm Cycling Shoe Insoles
- Made from carbon fiber
- Firm arch support
- Thin ventilated top cover
- Not customized
- Different arch heights
- Narrow heel fit
- Shipping fees are not included
For cyclists who prioritize firm arch support, Tread Labs Lael Wilcox insoles are an excellent option. These insoles are crafted from 100% carbon fiber arch support, making them incredibly rigid and efficient at returning energy during each pedal stroke.
Ideal for cycling shoes with thin or no inserts, Tread Labs offers four different arch heights to accommodate varying support requirements. While they may not offer a perfect fit for all users since they're one-size-fits-all insoles, they are still a viable choice for cyclists seeking high-quality arch support in their cycling shoes.
» Read more: explore the best cycling shoes for flat feet
3. Best Comfort Insoles for Cycling Shoes
- Wide forefoot design
- Deep heel cup
- 60-day money-back guarantee
- Made for medium to high arch height
- Need to trim insole to fit shoe
- Takes up a lot of space in shoes
- Not custom-made
The Superfeet Trailblazer insoles are an excellent choice for cyclists experiencing back and hip pain. These insoles have been designed to improve power transfer and reduce internal knee rotation, which can alleviate discomfort in the hip and lower back. The wide forefoot and deep heel cup are also ideal for those with wider cycling shoes.
While these insoles do not have a specific arch height in mind, they can still provide overall comfort and support to the foot during cycling. It's worth noting that these insoles may not be suitable for those with specific foot problems requiring customized arch support.
4. Best Cork Insoles for Cycling Shoes
- Made with ReCORK recycled wine corks
- Shock absorbing
- Moldable orthopedic base
- Takes time to get the perfect fit
- Best suited for medium-fitting shoes
- Must be trimmed to fit shoes
- Medium cushioning
SOLE performance medium insoles are an eco-friendly option made from recycled wine corks, which offer excellent shock absorption for cycling shoes. These insoles come with metatarsal pads that improve forefoot comfort, making them an ideal choice for cyclists who experience discomfort in this area.
However, wear-moldable design means they may take some time to adjust to the shape of your feet, unlike custom-made orthotics that offer immediate support and comfort. Overall, these cork insoles are a great option for cyclists looking for an environmentally-friendly and shock-absorbing solution for their cycling shoes.
5. Best Thin Insoles for Cycling Shoes
- Different sizes available
- Thinner than other insoles
- Moisture-wicking materials
- Difficulty fitting to shoe
- Trimming may impact performance
- Not custom-made
- Higher heel arching
The Protalus T-100 Elite insoles are designed specifically for low-volume cycling shoes with removable inserts and provide excellent arch support with a thin and lightweight design. These insoles are available in various sizes, making it easier for users to find a perfect fit.
Protalus insoles offer both cushioning and alignment support to help reduce foot fatigue and discomfort during long rides. However, due to their slim profile, these insoles may not fit perfectly in all shoes, even with trimming, which may impact their effectiveness as cycling insoles.
6. Best Shock-Absorbing Insoles for Cycling Shoes
- Custom-made orthotics
- FSA and HSA eligible
- Lightweight and durable
- More expensive than alternatives
- Longer waiting period
- Thicker insole base
URthotics Active Insoles are a top choice for cycling enthusiasts who desire shock absorption and durability. These insoles are designed with custom arch support that follows the natural contours of your foot, providing excellent comfort and stability. The top layer of the insole is made from high-quality EVA material, which is known for its durability and long-lasting performance. The deep heel cup design maximizes protection and helps to alleviate pain.
Although these insoles are pricier than some other options on the market, they are eligible for HSA and FSA plans, making them a great investment for those looking for a durable and effective cycling insole.
7. Best Foam Insoles for Cycling Shoes
- Prevents foot and leg fatigue
- Made through 3D technology
- Improves body alignment
- Not specifically made for cycling
- Smooth insole covering
- Cannot be trimmed to fit shoe
- More costly than alternatives
FitMyFoot's Custom Arch Support Insoles are one of the best foam insoles for cycling shoes, specifically designed for athletic use. These insoles are custom-made to fit your feet perfectly, using state-of-the-art 3D printing technology to ensure a snug fit. The dynamic tuned arch design provides custom-positioned support in specific areas of the foot while remaining flexible in others, allowing for optimal energy transfer during cycling.
Additionally, these insoles come with a deep contoured heel cushion that provides all-day shock absorption and cushioning, relieving heel discomfort and preventing foot fatigue. The breathable fabric helps to keep your feet cool and sweat-free, making them perfect for intense cycling sessions. Overall, these durable and comfortable insoles are a great investment for any cycling enthusiast.
» Considering over-the-counter insoles? Compare custom orthotics vs OTC insoles
Transform Your Cycling Experience
If you're looking to enhance your performance, reduce your risk of injury, and transform your cycling experience from just an activity to something you truly enjoy, investing in custom orthotics is the way to go. With custom orthotics, the insoles are molded to fit your feet perfectly, providing the optimal support and cushioning you need to reach your potential on the bike.
So why settle for generic insoles when you can have a personalized solution that's tailored to your unique needs? Upgrade your cycling game with custom orthotics and see the difference for yourself.