Up To 75% OFF EVERYTHING + FREE shipping

4 Best Insoles for Loafers: Perfect Fit for Happy Feet

Let's explore the best insoles designed for loafers to enhance style and fit, providing much-needed foot support.

a man in a white shirt and blue and pink suspenders
By Babafemi Adebajo
Dorian Rhode
Edited by Dorian Rhode

Published February 22, 2024.

A close up of someone wearing loafers with custom insoles.

With their timeless style and versatility, loafers have become a staple in many wardrobes. However, while they offer a sleek look, they often lack the comfort needed for all-day wear. This can lead to discomfort and foot pain, especially for those with specific arch support needs.

Fortunately, custom insoles provide a practical solution, ensuring you can stride confidently in your favorite pair.

» Check out tips on how to clean your insoles

Our 4 Best Insoles for Loafers

  1. Overall Best Insoles for Loafers: Upstep Normal Everyday Activity
  2. Best Comfort Insoles for Loafers: Superfeet All-Purpose Cushion
  3. Best Affordable Insoles for Loafers: Sof Sole Men's Memory Foam Insoles
  4. Best Support Insoles for Loafers: Tread Labs Dash Short Insoles

Exploring Insole Options: Stylish Support for Loafers

Custom insoles can benefit your fit in various ways, such as:

  • Foot support: Generic insoles offer basic support, but custom orthotics provide the most personalized fit, addressing specific arch issues and foot pain.

  • Comfort: Thin insoles like carbon fiber options fit well in shallow loafers, while the thicker memory foam insoles offer more cushioning for deeper styles.

  • Style-specific features: Some insoles target loafer-specific needs, like built-in arch support for the ones lacking this feature or heel cups to prevent slippage in backless styles.

Overall best insoles for loafers


Upstep custom shoe orthotics for everyday activity
Insert Upstep's custom orthotic into a shoe
Presenting a Green Upstep's Everyday Custom Shoe Orthotics
Upstep's Everyday shoe orthotics presented out of the shipping box and in a shoe

Normal Everyday Activity Orthotics

Experience comfort with every step

Read the review


180-day money-back guarantee

Shipping and returns

Free shipping and returns in the US


FSA/HSA eligible

Payment plans

Klarna eligible; four interest-free payments

Upstep Everyday Activity Orthotics are the best overall insoles for loafers because they're molded to your unique foot shape. They ensure a snug fit within the loafer, reducing heel slippage and providing targeted support for your arches.

They have a durable Polypropylene shell for stability with cushioning mid-layers to help balance support with comfort.

This insole helps ease foot fatigue, common in loafers without built-in arch support. They are perfect for people experiencing mild pain or discomfort while wearing loafers for short periods of up to 4 hours.

Custom-molded to individual feet

Improved fit

Enhanced Comfort

Not suitable for intense activities

Customization and delivery can take a while

Best comfort insoles for loafers


Superfeet All-Purpose Cushion Insoles
A pair of custom orthotics ideal for loafers to improve comfort
A pair of custom insoles with focus on the comfort technology making them a perfect fit for loafers
An insole

Superfeet All-Purpose Cushion


60-day satisfaction guarantee

Shipping and returns

Free shipping sitewide; possible fee charge for returns


Not disclosed on the website

Payment plans

Installment payments not available

Superfeet All-Purpose Cushion insoles for loafers help improve comfort and reduce stress on your feet, ankles, and knees.

These insoles can provide a better fit for loafers that are too big because of their contoured shape. They're also moisture-wicking, keeping feet dry and comfortable in loafers that might lack breathability.

Enhanced support and comfort

Moisture-wicking materials


Might not address specific foot concerns

Not specific for loafers

Can potentially cause problems if worn for long hours

Best affordable insoles for loafers


A pair of memory foam insoles ideal for wearing inside loafers
A blue and grey insole features a flexible and slim design perfect for loafers
The back of a single blue insole ideal for loafers
A single blue and grey insole features top cover treatment to prevent odor

Sof Sole Men's Memory Foam Comfort Shoe Insoles


Depends on the payment method used during purchase at the time

Shipping and returns

Shipping costs may vary, Free returns


Not FSA/HSA eligible

Payment plans

Installment payments not available

Sof Sole Memory Foam insoles for loafers have a thin and flexible design that fits well in most shoes without adding bulk or tightness. Plus, it's a budget-friendly option compared to expensive insoles often sold for loafers.

They are ideal for people who experience mild arch pain or discomfort in loafers, as the memory foam and deep heel cup could provide some relief.


Personalized comfort

Prevents heel slip

Not custom-made

Limited support

Not specifically designed for loafers

Best support insoles for loafers


A pair of black and yellow insoles ideal for loafers
A pair of black and yellow insoles considered the best for loafers
A pair of yellow insoles that can be worn inside loafers
A yellow insole that can be worn with loafers

Tread Labs Dash Short Insoles


Lifetime guarantee on repairs

Shipping and returns

Free shipping within the US; Free returns on domestic orders within 90 days of purchase


Not disclosed on the website

Payment plans

Shop Pay eligible; 4 interest-free payments

Dash Short features ultra-thin carbon fiber arch support. This material provides exceptionally strong and rigid stability, unlike most insoles designed for comfort in loafers.

These insoles for loafers are perfect for athletes looking to enhance performance through arch support and those with other foot-related issues.

Endorsement by podiatrists through the APMA Seal of Acceptance enhances their reputation for producing one of the best quality insoles for loafers.

Great arch support



Rigid design

Not for specific foot needs

Expensive for a generic insole

Common Discomforts and Challenges Associated with Loafers

Insoles can tackle the following issues:

  • Arch pain and discomfort: Insoles with good arch support can significantly alleviate pain for those with flat feet or fallen arches.
  • Fatigue and pressure: Cushioning layers in insoles absorb impact and distribute pressure more evenly, reducing foot fatigue throughout the day.
  • Odors: Closed-toe loafers with minimal ventilation can trap moisture and lead to odor. Breathable and moisture-wicking insoles can help combat this problem.
  • Heel pain and slippage: Heel cups in insoles stabilize the heel, reducing pain and preventing slippage in loafers.

» Discover what conditions custom orthotics are prescribed for

The Perfect Fit: Enhancing Loafer Comfort

While certain insoles are washable by hand, others might need specialized sprays. Always follow the cleaning instructions provided by the insole manufacturer. When drying them, ensure they air dry thoroughly before putting them back into your loafers to avoid moisture buildup and odor.

Additionally, consider rotating them frequently to give each pair a chance to air out and regain their shape. Regularly cleaning and caring for your loafers according to their material can also indirectly contribute to prolonging the lifespan of the insoles.

Choosing the right insoles for your loafers is crucial for achieving support and style. With a wide range of orthotics designed to enhance athletic performance and address various foot conditions, Upstep prioritizes your comfort and foot health. So take the first step today towards happier, healthier feet.